Business

From R5m to broke: How retirees destroy their wealth

Partnered Content|Published

Enjoying retirement: The rewards of smart financial planning.

Image: Supplied

Many often face financial strain within ten years of retirement due to avoidable mistakes.

You've worked for 40 years, saved diligently and accumulated R5 million for retirement. You should be set for life, right? Wrong. Shockingly, many South African retirees with substantial savings find themselves struggling financially within a decade of retiring. Here's how they destroy their wealth – and how you can avoid the same fate.

The Golden Equation, your ‘thriving not surviving’ formula

Before understanding how wealth gets destroyed, you need to grasp what we call the ‘Golden Equation’ for retirement capital sustainability:
Investment returns ≥ inflation rate + fees + income drawdown

Balance this equation, and it becomes very difficult to run out of money, all other things being equal. Ignore it, and even R5 million can disappear surprisingly quickly.

You can get straightforward, simple facts about your retirement investments from a 10X retirement expert at no cost to you. Just get in touch.

Mistake #1: Drawing down too aggressively

The biggest wealth destroyer is excessive withdrawals. Many retirees, seeing R5 million in their account, think they can afford to draw 8%, 10% or even more annually. After all, what's R400 000 from a R5 million pot?

Here's the reality: if you draw 8% annually from R5 million (R400 000 per year), add typical fees of 3% (and factor in 6% worth of inflation), you would need a 17% annual investment return just to break even. Even in good years, that is probably unlikely and completely unsustainable.

Did you know? 10X Investments has a range of carefully curated funds aimed at producing the long-term returns you need, regardless of your life stage or situation.

The result? Within a decade or so, your drawdowns may hit the regulatory limit of 17.5% of your remaining capital. At this point, you’re almost definitely going to run out of money.

The 4% rule: Your wealth preservation lifeline

International research, particularly William Bengen's groundbreaking 1994 study, established the "4% rule". Take 4% of your retirement savings in your first year, adjust that amount for inflation, and your money stands a good chance of lasting 30 years or more.

Applied to our R5 million example: draw R200 000 in the first year (R16 667 per month), then increase this amount each year to keep pace with inflation. This rate has survived market crashes, high inflation periods, and various economic cycles.

The 4% rule works because it respects sequence-of-returns risk – the danger of poor market performance early in retirement when you have the most capital and are therefore most vulnerable to large losses.

Mistake #2: Feeding the fee monster silently devouring your wealth

Even if you follow the 4% rule, high fees can still destroy your wealth. Consider two hypothetical scenarios for our R5 million retiree:

High-fee scenario (3% annually):

  • Annual drawdown: R200 000 (R16 667 per month)
  • Annual fees: R150 000 (R12 500 per month to service providers)
  • Total annual depletion: R350 000

Low-fee scenario (0.85% annually):

  • Annual drawdown: R200 000 (R16 667 per month)
  • Annual fees: R42 500 (R3 542 per month to service providers)
  • Total annual depletion: R242 500

The difference? R107 500 annually stays invested and compounds in the low-fee scenario. Over 20 years, this could extend the longevity of your savings by 5-15 years.

Feel like your investments could be doing more for you? Did you know you can get a free comparison report from 10X Investments?

Mistake #3: Not being ready for changing expenses

Many retirees assume their expenses will decrease in retirement. Often, the opposite occurs:

  • Rising healthcare costs: Medical expenses typically increase significantly with age. Without employer contributions to medical aid, these costs can consume an ever-growing portion of your income.
  • Lifestyle expansion: Early retirement often means more travel, hobbies and leisure activities. Many retirees spend more in their first decade of retirement than they did in their working years.
  • Home maintenance: As you age, you may need to hire services you previously managed yourself, such as gardening, cleaning or home repairs.
  • Inflation’s impact: Fixed expenses like municipal rates, insurance and utilities continue to rise, but your capital growth may not match these increases.

Mistake #4: Panic-selling

Market volatility tests even wealthy retirees' nerves. Watching R5 million drop to R4 million during a market correction can trigger panic. Many retirees make the fatal mistake of switching to ‘safer’ investments or cashing out when markets are down.

This locks in losses permanently. Instead of allowing time for recovery, they effectively guarantee a lower income for the rest of their lives. Those retiring at 60 could have 20 or more years ahead of them, which is plenty of time to recover from temporary market downturns.

A real-world example: The R5 million that became R500 000

Meet John, who retired in 2015 with R5 million (this example is for illustrative purposes only):

  • Years 1-3: Drew 8% annually (R400 000+) for extensive travel and home renovations
  • Year 4: Market correction panicked him into switching to cash investments
  • Years 5-7: Continued paying high fees (3.2% annually) while making larger withdrawals
  • Year 8: Portfolio worth R2.1 million, forcing a significant reduction in lifestyle
  • Year 10: Portfolio worth R500 000, with a drawdown rate hitting 17.5%

Sadly, our imaginary John is in a situation faced by thousands of real South Africans. Their mistake isn't having too little money – it is mismanaging what they have. To avoid John's fate, it may be a good idea to consider the following:

  • Respect the 4% rule: Start conservatively. You can always increase spending if your investments outperform.
  • Minimise fees ruthlessly: Every 1% in fee savings can extend your money's longevity by years.
  • Maintain growth exposure: Even in retirement, keep a significant amount of money in growth assets to combat inflation.
  • Plan for sequence risk: Consider keeping 2-3 years’ worth of expenses in cash to avoid selling growth assets during market downturns.
  • Review annually: Adjust your strategy based on portfolio performance and life changes.

 

The tragedy is watching retirees destroy wealth through preventable mistakes. The Golden Equation isn't just theory – it's a practical tool for ensuring your money lasts as long as you do.

 The content herein is provided as general information and does not constitute financial advice. 10X Investments is an authorised FSP (number 28250). The 10X Living Annuity is underwritten by Guardrisk Life Limited.